A paper and presentation for the 17th International System Safety Conference

From Bridges and Rockets, Lessons for Software Systems

C. Michael Holloway; NASA Langley Research Center; Hampton, Virginia

Keywords: safety, high integrity systems, software engineering, accident analysis, history

Abstract

Although differences exist between building software systems and building physical structures such as bridges and rockets, enough similarities exist that software engineers can learn lessons from failures in traditional engineering disciplines. This paper draws lessons from two well-known failures--the collapse of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge in 1940 and the destruction of the space shuttle Challenger in 1986--and applies these lessons to software system development. The following specific applications are made: (1) the verification and validation of a software system should not be based on a single method, or a single style of methods; (2) the tendency to embrace the latest fad should be overcome; and (3) the introduction of software control into safety-critical systems should be done cautiously.

I also gave a presentation based on this paper at the 2001 Military and Aerospace Applications of Programmable Devices and Technologies International Conference external link at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory on 13 September 2001. Here is a photograph taken during that presentation.

Note: The external link tag identifies links that are outside of the NASA domain.


Curator and Responsible Official: C. Michael Holloway
last modified: 15 September 1999 (08:09:55)